Three Mugs by Mistake
Created by Camila S. in ASHLAND, KY · 21 September 2026
The story behind it
I'd put three mugs on the cabin counter before my sister pointed at the spare. It was our first trip without Mum, and I'd packed her usual vanilla biscuits too. We hadn't known whether coming back was a good idea. My sister made the tea while I carried two chairs onto the cedar porch. There were wet leaves stuck underneath them. We sat facing the woods and talked about Mum's insistence on bringing proper cups on holiday. Then my sister asked for a biscuit. I passed her the tin and put the spare mug back in the cupboard.
I told Aura I wanted something warm, woody and comforting. It picked up on the biscuits I'd packed and the cedar porch where we'd sat, and suggested vanilla from Mysterious Amber alongside cedarwood to match those details.
What is in it
Top
First 15 minutes
- Pepper 5.8%
Heart
The character of the scent
- Lily of the valley 1.7%
- Incense 1.6%
- Milk 1.4%
Base
What stays on skin
- Vanilla 25.5%
- Cedarwood 20.1%
- Sandalwood 18.3%
- Dry woods 7.7%
- Musk 7.3%
- Tonka bean 3.9%
- Incense 3.6%
- Milk 3.2%
Fragrances with notes in common
-
Similar to Penhaligon's Babylon
Shared notes: vanilla, cedarwood, sandalwood -
Similar to Amouage Lustre
Shared notes: vanilla, cedarwood, sandalwood -
Similar to Diptyque Tam Dao
Shared notes: vanilla, cedarwood, sandalwood
These fragrance references are showcased to help you explore familiar scent profiles through shared notes. Every Scircle creation is unique and is not intended to replicate the fragrances shown. Scircle is independent of and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or a licensee of the brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Real people. Real scents. Real “what are you wearing?” moments.
Join the circle and see what people say about their one-of-a-kind formula.
FAQs
What does Three Mugs by Mistake smell like?
It opens with pepper, moves into lily of the valley, incense, and milk at the heart, and settles into vanilla, cedarwood, and sandalwood on the skin. The notes above show how much of each ingredient sits in the top, the heart, and the base.
Is Three Mugs by Mistake a dupe of Penhaligon's Babylon?
No. Three Mugs by Mistake is an original Scircle formula, not a copy of Penhaligon's Babylon. They share vanilla, cedarwood, and sandalwood, so it may feel familiar if you like Penhaligon's Babylon, but the blend is its own.
Scircle is independent of and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or a licensee of the brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Can I try Three Mugs by Mistake before buying a full bottle?
Of course! You can order Three Mugs by Mistake as a 5 ml Sniff before committing to a 20 ml bottle. Like every Scircle fragrance, it is an Eau de Parfum, freshly blended when you order.
Can I change Three Mugs by Mistake?
Absolutely! Love Three Mugs by Mistake but wish it had a little more vanilla, a touch of musk, or a fresher finish? Select Customize this scent with Aura to adapt it to your preferences. Your version becomes a new creation inspired by this one.