Skip to content
Create Your Story
The Pencilled Question Mark scent board Woody · Cedarwood

The Pencilled Question Mark

Created by Grace · 8 June 2026

The story behind it

I couldn't work out why someone had pencilled a question mark beside the locked door in the illustration. My friend had given me the old ghost-story collection without reading it. The picture showed an empty courtyard, moss between the paving stones, and that door. I checked the story for a mention of it, but there wasn't one. The previous owner hadn't marked anything else. I read three more stories with the television off, then checked the picture again. Before bed, I put it on my wooden bookshelf with a scrap of paper marking the page.

I told Aura I wanted something mysterious, woody and earthy for home. It picked out the wooden bookshelf and the moss in that courtyard illustration, recommending cedarwood and moss to match those two details rather than making the formula sweet.

What is in it

Top

First 15 minutes

  • Pepper 6.4%
  • Bergamot 5.2%
  • Geranium 0.9%

Heart

The character of the scent

  • Patchouli 3.1%
  • Jasmine 2.9%
  • Geranium 2.1%

Base

What stays on skin

  • Cedarwood 29.2%
  • Leather 12.0%
  • Dry woods 8.4%
  • Moss 7.3%
  • Patchouli 7.2%
  • Musk 7.0%
  • Vetiver 4.4%
  • Sandalwood 2.6%
  • Ciste labdanum 1.5%

Fragrances with notes in common

These fragrance references are showcased to help you explore familiar scent profiles through shared notes. Every Scircle creation is unique and is not intended to replicate the fragrances shown. Scircle is independent of and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or a licensee of the brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Real people. Real scents. Real “what are you wearing?” moments.

Join the circle and see what people say about their one-of-a-kind formula.

Customer feedback

FAQs

What does The Pencilled Question Mark smell like?

It opens with pepper, bergamot, and geranium, moves into patchouli and jasmine at the heart, and settles into cedarwood, leather, and dry woods on the skin. The notes above show how much of each ingredient sits in the top, the heart, and the base.

Is The Pencilled Question Mark a dupe of Penhaligon's Marylebone Wood?

No. The Pencilled Question Mark is an original Scircle formula, not a copy of Penhaligon's Marylebone Wood. They share cedarwood, leather, and patchouli, so it may feel familiar if you like Penhaligon's Marylebone Wood, but the blend is its own.

Scircle is independent of and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or a licensee of the brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Can I try The Pencilled Question Mark before buying a full bottle?

Of course! You can order The Pencilled Question Mark as a 5 ml Sniff before committing to a 20 ml bottle. Like every Scircle fragrance, it is an Eau de Parfum, freshly blended when you order.

Can I change The Pencilled Question Mark?

Absolutely! Love The Pencilled Question Mark but wish it had a little more vanilla, a touch of musk, or a fresher finish? Select Customize this scent with Aura to adapt it to your preferences. Your version becomes a new creation inspired by this one.

More questions about Scircle Stories