Skip to content
Create Your Story
My Old Pencil Tray scent board Woody · Vanilla

My Old Pencil Tray

Created by Justin C. in Marietta, GA, GA · 1 November 2026

The story behind it

I'd put my old wooden pencil tray beside the keyboard, even though the new desk had a drawer for everything. It was my first week in the job. I still had to ask which cupboard held the envelopes, and I kept forgetting everyone's extension. I hadn't wanted to make a big thing of being new. I just wanted a few familiar things around while I learned. So I'd brought my usual vanilla biscuits too. When the woman opposite asked where I'd found the tray, I passed her the packet and turned it over to show her Dad's initials underneath.

I told Aura I wanted something warm and woody for everyday wear at work. It picked up on the wooden tray I'd brought from home and the biscuits beside it, pairing sandalwood with vanilla to match those familiar details.

What is in it

Top

First 15 minutes

  • Pepper 7.2%
  • Cardamom 3.0%
  • Red fruits 0.5%

Heart

The character of the scent

  • Milk 2.3%
  • Lily of the valley 1.4%
  • Cardamom 1.3%
  • Incense 1.3%
  • Red fruits 0.2%

Base

What stays on skin

  • Vanilla 18.7%
  • Sandalwood 17.0%
  • Musk 16.0%
  • Cedarwood 11.6%
  • Dry woods 6.8%
  • Milk 5.3%
  • Incense 2.9%
  • Tonka bean 2.5%
  • Ciste labdanum 1.9%

Fragrances with notes in common

These fragrance references are showcased to help you explore familiar scent profiles through shared notes. Every Scircle creation is unique and is not intended to replicate the fragrances shown. Scircle is independent of and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or a licensee of the brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Real people. Real scents. Real “what are you wearing?” moments.

Join the circle and see what people say about their one-of-a-kind formula.

Customer feedback

FAQs

What does My Old Pencil Tray smell like?

It opens with pepper, cardamom, and red fruits, moves into milk, lily of the valley, and incense at the heart, and settles into vanilla, sandalwood, and musk on the skin. The notes above show how much of each ingredient sits in the top, the heart, and the base.

Is My Old Pencil Tray a dupe of Maison Margiela Replica : Afternoon Delight?

No. My Old Pencil Tray is an original Scircle formula, not a copy of Maison Margiela Replica : Afternoon Delight. They share vanilla, sandalwood, and musk, so it may feel familiar if you like Maison Margiela Replica : Afternoon Delight, but the blend is its own.

Scircle is independent of and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or a licensee of the brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Can I try My Old Pencil Tray before buying a full bottle?

Of course! You can order My Old Pencil Tray as a 5 ml Sniff before committing to a 20 ml bottle. Like every Scircle fragrance, it is an Eau de Parfum, freshly blended when you order.

Can I change My Old Pencil Tray?

Absolutely! Love My Old Pencil Tray but wish it had a little more vanilla, a touch of musk, or a fresher finish? Select Customize this scent with Aura to adapt it to your preferences. Your version becomes a new creation inspired by this one.

More questions about Scircle Stories